DVD2one Alternatives and Best Settings for QualityDVD2one was a popular DVD reauthoring tool that compressed dual-layer or two-disc DVD releases down to a single-disc size while attempting to preserve the original audio and video quality. Although DVD2one itself is discontinued and often incompatible with modern systems, many alternatives and workflows can achieve equal or better results today. This article surveys the best DVD2one alternatives, explains the core principles of high-quality DVD compression, and provides recommended settings and practical step‑by‑step workflows for preserving image and audio quality when shrinking DVDs.
Why choose an alternative to DVD2one?
- DVD2one is outdated and may not run on modern OSes.
- New tools support modern codecs, GPU acceleration, and improved filters.
- Contemporary workflows give finer control over compression, encoding, and chapter/ subtitle handling.
- Open-source tools allow reproducible, transparent results.
Core concepts: what matters for quality when shrinking a DVD
- Source quality: a clean, well-authored DVD with minimal studio noise yields the best results.
- Target size: typical single-layer DVD capacity is 4.7 GB; dual-layer is 8.5 GB. Knowing your target size drives bitrate allocation.
- Video codec: DVD video is MPEG-2 on disc. Reauthoring can keep MPEG-2 with recompression or transcode to a more efficient codec (H.264/AVC or H.265/HEVC) for long-term storage or playback on software/hardware that supports them.
- Bitrate control: use two-pass or multi-pass variable bitrate (VBR) encoding for consistent quality.
- Audio handling: prefer keeping original audio tracks when possible. If you must transcode, use high bitrates and modern codecs (AAC, Opus) compatible with your target playback environment.
- Filters and preprocessing: deinterlacing, denoising, and smart resizing can significantly improve perceived quality after recompression.
- Subtitles and menus: reauthoring tools differ in how they preserve or recreate menus and subtitles — reauthor if you need menus, remux or repackage if you only need the main feature.
Best modern alternatives to DVD2one
Below are reliable tools for different workflows and user skill levels.
- HandBrake — user-friendly transcoder for ripping and reencoding DVDs to H.264/H.265; good presets and filters. No native menu reauthoring.
- MakeMKV + HandBrake — MakeMKV extracts (rips) complete titles to MKV preserving original streams; HandBrake reencodes as needed.
- DVD Shrink (old) — similar functionally to DVD2one but outdated and Windows-only; still used by some with compatibility workarounds.
- DVDFab Reauthor / DVD Copy — commercial suites that offer reauthoring, compression, and menu handling.
- DVDRebuilder — advanced reauthoring focused on MPEG-2 optimization and high-quality transcode; often considered the closest modern equivalent to DVD2one for MPEG-2 reauthoring.
- AVStoDVD / MeGUI — advanced, scriptable pipelines for high-quality encoding; steeper learning curve but powerful.
- FFmpeg — command-line tool for custom pipelines, remuxing, reencoding; extremely flexible.
- VideoReDo — useful for editing and saving recompressed MPEG-2 without full reencode (smart rendering) when cutting/trimming.
- StaxRip — front-end for many encoders (x264, x265, NVEnc) with presets and detailed options.
Recommended workflows (by goal)
A. Preserve original MPEG-2 (minimal quality loss, keep menus)
- Use DVD ripping tool that preserves VOB structure (e.g., MakeMKV can extract titles but outputs MKV; better: IFOBackup or simply copy the VIDEO_TS folder).
- Use DVDRebuilder to reauthor and recompress intelligently: it performs smart recompression, uses filters, and focuses on preserving visual quality when reducing size.
- Choose “high quality” MPEG-2 encode settings inside DVDRebuilder or set a bitrate appropriate for your target size. Run two-pass or multipass.
- Test the resulting VIDEO_TS on target player software/hardware.
When keeping MPEG-2, you avoid artifacts introduced by re-encoding to modern codecs and maintain maximum compatibility with DVD players.
B. Reencode to H.264/H.265 for storage (best quality per size)
- Rip titles with MakeMKV (keeps original audio/subs).
- Open the MKV in HandBrake, StaxRip, or FFmpeg.
- Recommended encoder: H.264 (x264) for compatibility, H.265 (x265) for best efficiency (smaller files at equal quality).
- Use two-pass VBR or CRF:
- For x264: use CRF 18–20 for near‑transparent quality; CRF 20–22 for visually good but smaller files.
- For x265: CRF 22–24 yields similar perceived quality to x264 CRF 18–20.
- Tune options:
- x264 preset: medium or slower (slower = better compression).
- x265 preset: slower/tune for film.
- Set profile/level for compatibility (e.g., High for H.264).
- Keep original audio (AC3, DTS) if you want pass-through, or transcode to AAC/Opus if size and compatibility are priorities. For 5.1 audio, keep AC3 passthrough when target supports it.
- Add forced subtitles and soft subtitles as needed.
C. Quick/simple method (no menus, minimal tweaking)
- Rip with MakeMKV.
- Open in HandBrake and select a preset (e.g., “HQ 1080p30 Surround” or “Fast 480p30” depending on source).
- Adjust quality slider (CRF) or target bitrate to fit your desired size.
- Encode and verify.
Specific encoding settings for best perceived quality
- Target size calculation: bitrate_target = (target_bytes − audio_bytes − container_overhead) * 8 / duration_seconds.
- For single-disc (4.7 GB) with a 120-minute movie and 640 kbps audio: total video bitrate target ≈ let target_bytes = 4.7 GB ≈ 4.7 × 10^9 bytes; audio ~ 80 KB? (simpler: use bitrate calculator inside tools). For practical use, aim video average bitrate ~ 4,500–5,500 kbps for MPEG-2; for H.264, target average 1,500–3,500 kbps depending on resolution and motion.
Concise practical presets:
- MPEG-2 reauthoring (DVDRebuilder): variable bitrate aiming avg 4,800–5,800 kbps for 720×480 sources.
- x264 (720×480 source to 720×480 or upscale to 720p): CRF 18–20; preset = slow; tune = film; profile = high.
- x265: CRF 22–24; preset = slow.
Audio:
- Keep original AC3/DTS passthrough when possible.
- When transcoding 5.1 to AAC: use 384–512 kbps for good quality.
- For stereo AAC: 128–192 kbps is fine.
- For Opus (if target players support it): 96–160 kbps stereo for excellent quality.
Filters:
- Denoise (conservative: low strength) if source has grain that causes bitrate spikes.
- Deblock or light sharpening only when necessary.
- Deinterlace (or better, inverse telecine) if source is interlaced; use field-aware filters or yadif/nnedi3 in advanced workflows.
- Resize with high-quality scaler (Lanczos or Spline36) if scaling is needed.
Example FFmpeg commands
Reencode to H.264 (two-pass example — pass 1):
ffmpeg -i input.mkv -c:v libx264 -b:v 2500k -pass 1 -an -f mp4 /dev/null pass 2:
ffmpeg -i input.mkv -c:v libx264 -b:v 2500k -pass 2 -c:a aac -b:a 192k output.mp4 Single-pass CRF example:
ffmpeg -i input.mkv -c:v libx264 -crf 20 -preset slow -c:a copy output.mkv Use hardware encoders (NVENC, QSV) for speed but increase bitrate or slightly lower quality preset to match x264 quality.
Tips, troubleshooting, and final checks
- Always test-encode a short clip (1–3 minutes) to evaluate the visual effect of settings before committing to a full transcode.
- Use two-pass VBR if you need to match an exact target size; use CRF for quality-first workflows without strict size limits.
- Check for A/V sync issues after reauthoring; re-muxing or adjusting timestamps may be necessary.
- Preserve chapters and forced subtitles by using MKV containers during intermediate steps.
- For preserving menus, prefer full reauthoring tools (DVDFab, DVDRebuilder, commercial suites) — many transcoders discard original DVD menus.
Closing notes
Choosing the right alternative and settings depends on your priorities: compatibility and preserving DVD-style playback favors MPEG-2 reauthoring; long-term storage and best quality-per-byte favor H.264/H.265 reencoding. Start with a short test encode, keep original audio when compatibility matters, and use two-pass or CRF strategies depending on whether you need an exact target size or maximum visual fidelity.
Leave a Reply